‘Music needs a human component to be of any value’: Guardian readers on the growing use of AI in music

The Guardian — Artificial IntelligenceWednesday, December 17, 2025 at 11:00:31 AM
‘Music needs a human component to be of any value’: Guardian readers on the growing use of AI in music
  • The rise of AI-generated music is reshaping the music industry, with recent AI songs achieving top positions on Spotify and Billboard charts. This trend has sparked debates about the implications of AI in music creation, particularly regarding the authenticity and value of music without a human touch. Jorja Smith's label has even requested royalties from an AI-generated song that utilized her vocal style, highlighting the complexities of copyright in this new landscape.
  • This development is significant for artists and the music industry as it raises questions about the role of human creativity in music production. The call for fair compensation for artists whose work is used to train AI models underscores the need for clearer regulations and protections for musicians in an increasingly automated environment. As AI tools become more prevalent, the industry must navigate the balance between innovation and the preservation of artistic integrity.
  • The growing use of AI in creative fields reflects broader societal debates about technology's role in art and labor. While some embrace AI as a tool for enhancing creativity, others express concerns about its potential to undermine human artistry and employment. The introduction of features by platforms like Spotify that allow users to customize their music experience further complicates this landscape, as it raises questions about the personalization of art and the implications for artists' livelihoods.
— via World Pulse Now AI Editorial System

Was this article worth reading? Share it

Recommended apps based on your readingExplore all apps
Continue Readings
School security AI flagged clarinet as a gun. Exec says it wasn’t an error.
NegativeArtificial Intelligence
A middle school experienced a lockdown after an AI security system mistakenly identified a clarinet as a firearm, leading to panic among students and staff. The executive responsible for the AI stated that this incident was not an error, raising concerns about the reliability of AI in critical safety situations.
AI's 2025 carbon footprint may match New York City, report estimates
NegativeArtificial Intelligence
A recent report estimates that by the end of 2025, the carbon footprint of global AI systems could match that of New York City, raising concerns about the environmental impact of artificial intelligence technologies. Additionally, the water consumption associated with AI may rival that of the global bottled water market, highlighting the resource demands of these systems.
OpenAI launches app store, making ChatGPT your digital assistant
PositiveArtificial Intelligence
OpenAI has launched an app store for ChatGPT, allowing users to access various services like Spotify, DoorDash, and Dropbox directly within the chat interface. This development enhances the functionality of ChatGPT, positioning it as a more versatile digital assistant for users.
AI boom has caused same CO2 emissions in 2025 as New York City, report claims
NegativeArtificial Intelligence
A recent study claims that the AI boom has resulted in carbon dioxide emissions equivalent to those of New York City by 2025, highlighting the environmental costs associated with the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence technologies. The research also indicates that water usage related to AI now surpasses global bottled-water demand.
Can AI really help us discover new materials?
NeutralArtificial Intelligence
Recent discussions have emerged regarding the potential of artificial intelligence (AI) to aid in the discovery of new materials, amidst a backdrop of skepticism about the actual benefits of AI technologies. While many headlines suggest that AI could revolutionize various sectors, including materials science, there is a growing concern that much of the excitement may be overstated.
AI video translation shows promise but humans still hold the edge
NeutralArtificial Intelligence
Recent research from the University of East Anglia indicates that while AI video translation technology is advancing, it still cannot fully replace human translators. The study highlights the limitations of AI in capturing nuances and cultural context in translations, suggesting that human expertise remains essential in this field.
Hands-On With AWS’s New AI “Frontier” Security Reviewer
NeutralArtificial Intelligence
AWS has unveiled its new AI-driven security reviewer, known as the 'Frontier' system, designed to enhance security measures for developers by automating code reviews and identifying vulnerabilities. This innovation was highlighted during the AWS re:Invent 2025 conference, showcasing the company's commitment to integrating AI into its services.
Local AI-Powered Search Engine Using SLM Embeddings
NeutralArtificial Intelligence
A local search engine has been developed utilizing AI-powered SLM embeddings, marking a significant advancement in search technology. This innovation aims to enhance the efficiency and accuracy of search results by leveraging sophisticated machine learning techniques.

Ready to build your own newsroom?

Subscribe to unlock a personalised feed, podcasts, newsletters, and notifications tailored to the topics you actually care about