‘Music needs a human component to be of any value’: Guardian readers on the growing use of AI in music

The Guardian TechnologyWednesday, December 17, 2025 at 11:00:31 AM
NeutralTechnology
‘Music needs a human component to be of any value’: Guardian readers on the growing use of AI in music
  • The rise of AI-generated music is reshaping the music industry, with recent AI songs achieving top positions on Spotify and Billboard charts. This trend has sparked debates about the implications of AI in music creation, particularly regarding the authenticity and value of music without a human touch. Jorja Smith's label has even requested royalties from an AI-generated song that utilized her vocal style, highlighting the complexities of copyright in this new landscape.
  • This development is significant for artists and the music industry as it raises questions about the role of human creativity in music production. The call for fair compensation for artists whose work is used to train AI models underscores the need for clearer regulations and protections for musicians in an increasingly automated environment. As AI tools become more prevalent, the industry must navigate the balance between innovation and the preservation of artistic integrity.
  • The growing use of AI in creative fields reflects broader societal debates about technology's role in art and labor. While some embrace AI as a tool for enhancing creativity, others express concerns about its potential to undermine human artistry and employment. The introduction of features by platforms like Spotify that allow users to customize their music experience further complicates this landscape, as it raises questions about the personalization of art and the implications for artists' livelihoods.
— via World Pulse Now AI Editorial System

Was this article worth reading? Share it

Recommended apps based on your readingExplore all apps
Continue Readings
YouTube Boots 2 Channels for Posting Fake AI Film Trailers
NegativeTechnology
YouTube has removed two channels that amassed a combined 2 million subscribers for posting fake film trailers generated by artificial intelligence. This action reflects the platform's ongoing efforts to combat misinformation and uphold content integrity amid rising concerns over AI-generated media.
It's not just RAM getting more expensive - the tools to make chips are set to explode in cost too, experts warn
NegativeTechnology
Chipmakers are facing rising costs not only for RAM but also for the tools required to manufacture chips, driven by advancements in technology and increasing demand for AI hardware. Experts warn that these escalating expenses could significantly impact the semiconductor industry.
School security AI flagged clarinet as a gun. Exec says it wasn’t an error.
NegativeTechnology
A middle school experienced a lockdown after an AI security system mistakenly identified a clarinet as a firearm, leading to panic among students and staff. The executive responsible for the AI stated that this incident was not an error, raising concerns about the reliability of AI in critical safety situations.
Google will turn the news into a custom podcast for you - free
PositiveTechnology
Google has launched an AI-generated podcast feature that allows users to receive daily news updates in a customized audio format. This innovation aims to enhance user engagement by transforming traditional news consumption into a more accessible and convenient experience.
OpenAI now accepting ChatGPT app submissions from third-party devs, launches App Directory
PositiveTechnology
OpenAI has initiated the acceptance of app submissions from third-party developers for integration into ChatGPT, alongside the launch of an App Directory accessible via the ChatGPT sidebar. This allows over 800 million users to discover and utilize new applications directly within their conversations.
UK actors vote to refuse to be digitally scanned in pushback against AI
NegativeTechnology
UK actors, represented by the performing arts union Equity, have overwhelmingly voted to refuse digital scanning on set, with 99% in favor. This decision aims to protect their likeness from being used by artificial intelligence without consent, marking a significant stance against AI's encroachment in the arts.
The Star Trek Holodeck just got closer – Apple’s new AI tool generates 3D scenes from your photos in under a second for VR memories
PositiveTechnology
Apple has introduced a new AI tool capable of transforming 2D images into 3D scenes in under one second, enhancing the potential for virtual reality experiences. This innovation aligns with the company's ongoing efforts to integrate advanced technology into user experiences, reminiscent of the fictional Holodeck from Star Trek.
Bosses are getting tired of AI at work, and preferring to hire humans for "specialist" roles once again
NeutralTechnology
Companies are increasingly shifting their hiring strategies, moving away from reliance on AI for various roles and opting to hire human specialists instead. This trend indicates a growing fatigue among employers regarding the capabilities of AI in the workplace.

Ready to build your own newsroom?

Subscribe to unlock a personalised feed, podcasts, newsletters, and notifications tailored to the topics you actually care about