Is the UK-France migrants returns deal workable?

BBC NewsWednesday, September 17, 2025 at 1:45:57 PM
Is the UK-France migrants returns deal workable?
A recent ruling by a High Court judge has temporarily blocked the return of a migrant to France, highlighting the complexities surrounding deportation plans. This decision raises questions about the effectiveness of the government's strategies and could signal challenges ahead for No 10 as they navigate immigration policies.
— Curated by the World Pulse Now AI Editorial System

Was this article worth reading? Share it

Recommended Readings
France braces for day of strikes amid political crisis
NegativeWorld Affairs
France is gearing up for a significant day of strikes, with around 800,000 people expected to protest against the government's budget plans. This demonstration marks a rare moment of unity among trade unions, as they aim to pressure new Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu to reconsider proposed budget cuts and address critical issues like wages, pensions, and public services. The outcome of this strike could have lasting implications for the government's policies and the public's trust in leadership.
France should have recognised Palestinian statehood years ago. The cynic in me asks: why now? | Rokhaya Diallo
NegativeWorld Affairs
Emmanuel Macron's recent announcement to recognize Palestinian statehood has sparked significant backlash from Israel and raised tensions with the United States. Critics question the timing of this decision, suggesting it may be an attempt by Macron to bolster his international standing amid domestic challenges. This move is crucial as it highlights the ongoing complexities of Middle Eastern politics and the struggle for Palestinian recognition on the global stage.
Starmer to recognise Palestinian state ‘after Trump state visit’
PositiveWorld Affairs
Keir Starmer is set to recognize a Palestinian state following Donald Trump's state visit to the UK, a move that aligns with similar actions from other nations like France and Canada at the upcoming UN summit. This recognition is significant as it reflects a growing international consensus on Palestinian statehood, especially if Israel fails to address humanitarian concerns in Gaza. Starmer's decision could influence global discussions on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and highlight the urgency of improving conditions in the region.
Opinion | Hamas Gets a Gentle Reproche
NegativeWorld Affairs
The recent U.N. approval of a French measure suggests that Hamas may be viewed as equally culpable as Israel in the ongoing conflict. This development is significant as it reflects a shift in international perceptions and could influence future diplomatic efforts in the region.
Shabana Mahmood accuses asylum seekers of making ‘vexatious, last-minute claims’
NegativeWorld Affairs
Shabana Mahmood has stirred controversy by accusing asylum seekers of making 'vexatious, last-minute claims' to evade deportation to France. This statement comes as the Home Office plans to review modern slavery laws to uphold Prime Minister Keir Starmer's controversial 'one in, one out' returns deal with France. The implications of these claims and the potential changes to the law could significantly impact the treatment of asylum seekers in the UK, raising concerns about their rights and the fairness of the immigration system.
Home Office to appeal temporary block on man's deportation under 'one in, one out' plan
NegativeWorld Affairs
The Home Office is set to challenge a High Court ruling that has temporarily halted the deportation of an Eritrean man to France as part of its controversial 'one in, one out' immigration policy. This appeal highlights ongoing tensions surrounding the government's approach to immigration and raises questions about the treatment of asylum seekers. The outcome could have significant implications for future deportation cases and the rights of individuals seeking refuge.
France’s new prime minister faces a bumpy ride with nationwide strikes ahead
NeutralWorld Affairs
France's new Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu is stepping into a challenging political landscape as he meets with leaders of the Socialist Party to discuss budget concessions. This dialogue is crucial as it could influence the final phase of President Emmanuel Macron's second term, especially with nationwide strikes looming. The outcome of these talks will not only impact the government's financial strategies but also the stability of Macron's administration during a pivotal time.
What the court decision to block deportation means for Labour’s ‘one in, one out’ deal with France
NegativeWorld Affairs
A recent court ruling has put a halt to the deportation of a 25-year-old Eritrean man, raising concerns about the future of the UK government's 'one in, one out' immigration deal with France. This decision is significant as it challenges the effectiveness of the current immigration policies and could lead to further legal scrutiny, impacting the Labour party's stance on immigration reform. The outcome of this case may influence public opinion and political discourse surrounding immigration in the UK.
French Socialists press Macron's new government for major budget concessions
NeutralWorld Affairs
Leaders of France's Socialist Party are engaging with new Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu to negotiate significant budget concessions. This meeting is crucial as it could influence the direction of President Emmanuel Macron's second term, highlighting the ongoing political dynamics in France. The outcome of these discussions may impact various social programs and economic policies, making it a key moment for both the government and the citizens.
‘One in, one out’ deal will go ahead, says Liz Kendall after last-minute injunction
NeutralWorld Affairs
Despite a recent high court ruling that temporarily blocked the deportation of an Eritrean man, UK Minister Liz Kendall has confirmed that the 'one in, one out' deal with France will proceed as planned. This ruling raised concerns about the implications for the agreement, but Kendall reassured that it will not undermine the basis of the deal. This development is significant as it highlights the ongoing discussions around immigration policies and international agreements between the UK and France.
Eritrean man wins block on removal to France under 'one in, one out' deal
PositiveWorld Affairs
An Eritrean man has successfully blocked his removal to France under a controversial 'one in, one out' migration deal. This decision is significant as it highlights ongoing legal challenges faced by migrants arriving in the UK by small boats, who were recently informed of imminent flights to France. The ruling not only impacts the individual case but also raises broader questions about the treatment of migrants and the policies governing their relocation.
France proposes ceiling on value of UK components in €150bn EU defence fund
NegativeWorld Affairs
France's recent proposal to limit the value of UK-produced military components in the EU's €150 billion defence fund could complicate the UK's negotiations for entry into the Safe scheme. This move, suggesting a 50% ceiling on UK components, raises concerns about the future collaboration between the UK and EU in defense projects, potentially impacting the role of British defense firms in European security initiatives.
Latest from World Affairs
Australia news live: Sussan Ley says Labor’s new emissions target ‘fails on both counts’ of cost and credibility
NegativeWorld Affairs
In recent news, Sussan Ley criticized Labor's new emissions target, claiming it fails in both cost and credibility. This statement comes as Prime Minister Albanese has unveiled a new climate target aimed at significantly reducing emissions over the next decade. Ley's comments highlight the ongoing debate about the effectiveness and feasibility of Australia's climate policies, which is crucial as the country grapples with its environmental responsibilities and economic implications.
Trump celebrates Jimmy Kimmel suspension; some networks replace show with Charlie Kirk tribute – live
PositiveWorld Affairs
Donald Trump is celebrating the suspension of Jimmy Kimmel's show, which ABC has taken off the air indefinitely due to complaints about Kimmel's comments regarding the killing of rightwing activist Charlie Kirk. This situation highlights the ongoing tensions in media representation and political discourse. Additionally, Trump claims that his administration has reached a deal with China to keep TikTok operating in the US, although details remain uncertain, particularly regarding control over the platform's algorithm. This news is significant as it reflects the intersection of entertainment, politics, and international relations.
US judge orders Mahmoud Khalil deported citing ‘misrepresented facts’ on green card form
NegativeWorld Affairs
A US immigration judge has ordered the deportation of pro-Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil, citing undisclosed information on his green card application. This ruling, which could send him to Algeria or Syria, has raised concerns among his supporters, who argue that he remains protected from immigration enforcement while a separate federal case is ongoing. The situation highlights the complexities of immigration law and the potential consequences for activists involved in political movements.
Lionel Messi nears contract extension with Inter Miami: Report
PositiveWorld Affairs
Lionel Messi is reportedly on the verge of extending his contract with Inter Miami, which is exciting news for fans and the club alike. This multi-year deal not only signifies Messi's commitment to the MLS but also highlights the growing appeal of soccer in the United States. His presence continues to elevate the league's profile and attract more attention to the sport.
No more forced job cuts at Australian National University, staff told, but $250m restructure to continue
NeutralWorld Affairs
The Australian National University has announced that there will be no forced job cuts as part of its ongoing $250 million restructure, which is significant for staff morale and job security. This decision comes alongside the news that the Australian National Dictionary Centre has received support from an anonymous donor, ensuring its continued operation. However, uncertainty remains regarding the future of the ANU music school, highlighting the complexities of the university's restructuring efforts. This situation is important as it reflects broader trends in higher education funding and staffing.
France braces for day of strikes amid political crisis
NegativeWorld Affairs
France is gearing up for a significant day of strikes, with around 800,000 people expected to protest against the government's budget plans. This demonstration marks a rare moment of unity among trade unions, as they aim to pressure the new Prime Minister, Sébastien Lecornu, to reconsider cuts affecting wages, pensions, and public services. The outcome of this protest could have lasting implications for the government's approach to economic policy and social welfare.