Giving a review zero stars sets a dreadful precedent. But here are the one-star shockers I’d downgrade | Peter Bradshaw

The Guardian•Thursday, November 6, 2025 at 4:47:07 PM

Peter Bradshaw discusses the fallout from Kim Kardashian's critically panned TV show, 'All's Fair,' which received an unprecedented zero-star rating from Lucy Mangan. This extreme rating has sparked a debate about the integrity of the star-rating system in reviews, suggesting that if zero stars become the new norm for expressing dissatisfaction, it could diminish the value of ratings altogether. This matters because it raises questions about how we evaluate and critique media, potentially leading to a shift in how audiences perceive quality in entertainment.

— via World Pulse Now AI Editorial System

Read Original

Was this article worth reading? Share it

Recommended Readings

The Guardian2 days ago

Share your zero-star cultural disasters

NeutralWorld Affairs

The Guardian is inviting readers to share their own zero-star cultural disasters, a rare opportunity since the publication has only issued 18 such reviews in its history. This initiative not only highlights the unique nature of zero-star ratings but also encourages public engagement in discussing cultural experiences that fell flat. It's a chance for readers to reflect on their own disappointments in entertainment and share them with a wider audience.

Read full article

via The Guardian

The Guardian2 days ago

Is Kim Kardashian’s legal drama All’s Fair really the worst TV show of all time?

NegativeWorld Affairs

Ryan Murphy's new show, All's Fair, featuring Kim Kardashian, has been met with overwhelmingly negative reviews, with some critics even giving it zero stars. This backlash highlights the challenges of high-profile productions and raises questions about audience expectations and the standards of television today. The extreme reactions to the show could impact its viewership and future projects in the industry.

Read full article

via The Guardian

The Guardian3 days ago

Director of Kim Kardashian show All’s Fair responds to scathing reviews: ‘Hopefully opinions will change’

NegativeWorld Affairs

Anthony Hemingway, the director and executive producer of the legal drama 'All's Fair,' has responded to the harsh criticism the show has received. Despite the negative reviews, he remains hopeful that viewers' opinions will shift over time. This situation highlights the challenges faced by creators in the television industry, especially when a show doesn't resonate with critics but may still find an audience.

Read full article

via The Guardian

The Guardian3 days ago

The Guardian has only ever published 15 zero-star reviews. Here they all are

NegativeWorld Affairs

The Guardian has published only 15 zero-star reviews in its history, and Kim Kardashian's new legal drama, All's Fair, has made the list. This review highlights the show's significant shortcomings, marking it as a notable failure in television. Such low ratings are rare and draw attention to the expectations viewers have for high-profile productions, especially those featuring celebrities like Kardashian. This serves as a reminder of the critical role reviews play in shaping public perception and the entertainment landscape.

Read full article

via The Guardian